Bands that sound better live.

[naphazoline]

What bands do you think sound better live,either at the concert/gig,or recorded live,then they do studio recorded?

One that springs to mind,is Judas Priest.

I have several of their live albums,and each one seems better sound quality then the studio ones.

Anyone can get it right in a studio environment,taking as long as it takes to nail it,but a true sign of a good band to me,is when they are better live.

There's been a hell of a lot more bands that sound bad when they play live,and after seeing a Guns 'n' Roses concert in America that was aired on TV a few years back,i'd have to say that they were one of them.
The crowd attending wouldn't have disagreed with me either,as they were booing them to the point that G 'n' R started abusing them.They were all WAY too wasted to play any good at all.

So lets see what bands that you like better live.

[Owl]

Two that spring to mind are Simple Minds and Eagles.

[Drew]

Iron Maiden sound the same, live or studio.

Lord sound great live.

I thught the Eagles sucked arse, but that had nothing to do with sound quality.

[SixPackBack]

Artic Monkeys sounded better live.......best concert I have been too.

[ynot slow]

Clapton,Tina Turner.

[Big Dave]

Hmmmm. Can't think of any off the top of my head. I can easily nominate several that were significantly worse.

[Laava]

Midnight Oil

[Trudes]

Muse.
Metallica.

[SixPackBack]

Midnight Oil

Second that Pete Garrat kicks arse.

[Usarka]

Afro Celt Sound System.

[naphazoline]

Artic Monkeys sounded better live.......best concert I have been too.

Arctic Monkeys are a band i REALLY like.They are a breath of fresh air for a modern band.


Hmmmm. Can't think of any off the top of my head. I can easily nominate several that were significantly worse.

Feel free to name some.
It's amazing how some bands rely totally on the sound engineering wizardry of the studio to mask a lack of talent.:laugh:

[Magua]

The Arcade Fire. I was never much of a fan of their albums, but they were amazing on stage.

[Kiwi Graham]

AccaDacca dude, role on February :Punk:

[Dave Lobster]

Feel free to name some.
It's amazing how some bands rely totally on the sound engineering wizardry of the studio to mask a lack of talent.:laugh:

Depeche Mode. Utter, utter crap. I walked out well before the end.

The Who. Not impressed at all, considering the hype.

Smashing Pumpkins. Just a fucking noise. Very disappointing. Walked out.


Ones that I've seen that are better:

Sarah McLachlan.
Julieanne Regan.
Lloyd Cole.
New Order.
Iron Maiden. Seen them a few times. Top of their game, still.

[dogsnbikes]

KIZZ,SCORPIONS RAINBOW,DEEP PURPLE and the NOD all sound great Live,live recordings or studio recordings

[Big Dave]

Feel free to name some.
It's amazing how some bands rely totally on the sound engineering wizardry of the studio to mask a lack of talent.:laugh:

It's too subjective really. Angus could play an Acoustic Ukelele and your average bogon will assure you it's the greatest lead break in AC/DC history, because they were caught up in the euphoria of the moment, crowd and vibe.

The only band I can say that consistently failed to live up to my studio expectations was Cold Chisel - but I only ever saw them when Barnsey was on the piss - and they were terrible.

Dragon apparently had a rep for some stinkers when Marc was on the gear, but I only ever saw them rock.

Saint Bruce of E-street, hallowed be his band, gave me the irrits slightly with over-reprises, but I was expecting perfection - and only almost got it.

[Katman]

Tism.

I'd have never bought any of their albums if I could've seen them live every night.

[boman]

Well I did enjoy AC/DC on their Razors edge tour way back in 91, (I think). Thought they were fantastic live. Although I enjoy their music Live or recorded. The stage show was pretty awesome. Especially the extras like, For Those About To Rock's 21 gun salute, Hells Bells, Money Talks made a great show. Definitely looking forward to February.

:Punk:

[Solly]

A rubber band .......at a stretch :innocent:

[mctshirt]

Iva Davies and Icehouse - dragged along by a mate who was a fan and it turned out to be one of the best gigs I ever saw...huge night and far better than any record would have you believe

Dance Exponents for free on a Tuesday night at the Espy in Melbourne - 10 people in the bar and only half were there to see the unknown band from NZ. What made it memorable was they worked just as hard to get the other five people interested as they did when I'd paid $20 to see them play to a packed out pub back home.

Matt Johnson and Johnny Marr aka The The were impossibly better then the heavily produced record they made...impossibly great live

[Trudes]

Opshop are fantastic live... Shihad are great live too.... Go Kiwi!

[Cheshire Cat]

the Violent Femmes:Punk:

[Dirty_Harri]

I agree with Shihad
U2
Disturbed :Punk:

[Maha]

I was suprised how good Whitesnake and Poison sounded live.

[Big Dave]

Yea - all of these bands are great live.

For the show - and the way they accurately recreate the studio sound maybe.

[short-circuit]

Muse.
Metallica.

A fucken MEN to those two.

Oh and TOOL !!!!!!!

[Cheshire Cat]

pendulum and Bjork are just as good live as recorded!:wari:

[MaxB]

On my OE I went to the Monsters of Rock at Donnigton in '82. I was there to see Saxon and Hawkwind maaan.

But headliners Status Quo played a storming set for over 2 hours and had the crowd eating out of their hands. A lot of their albums were pretty bland but that night I understood why they were so popular.

About that time I saw Queen on their Hot Space tour which was a God-awful album. They get a special mention because the concert was going south as they played their new funk inspired sound. The crowd just didn't like it. About midway through Staying Power they changed gears and powered up the PA and won over the crowd with their old rock style.

Sign of a great band, the ability to sense the crowd and change the mood to suit.

[naphazoline]

.....Sign of a great band, the ability to sense the crowd and change the mood to suit.

That's good when a band does that.


Yea - all of these bands are great live.
For the show - and the way they accurately recreate the studio sound maybe.

That's what i'm talking about.....Forget about their theatrics,or the wow factor of being there,seeing them.

A band you can close your eyes to,and they SOUND better then their studio recordings.

[mctshirt]

the Violent Femmes:Punk:
Oh yeah - another great live band but their songs are meant to be played live

And a special mention to George Thorogood and the Destroyers - nothing out of the ordinary musically compared to the albums but those good ole boys sure do put on a show!

:Punk:

[Laava]

Wet to see The Church back in the day and the support act was the Mockers who were top class. Loads of people started leaving 2 songs in to the Church. Totally upstaged.

[MisterD]

For sheer Band-Audience-Band energy exchange, both New Model Army kicked the arse of any rock/metal/punk/grunge bands I've seen except Motorhead...