My old work say I owe them $5. Do I have to pay it back?

[Gareth123]

I'm probably going too. I pass them on my way to work each day so its not sending me outta my way. I'm just curious.

When I left the supermarket I worked at, they over paid me $5 in Xmas club vouchers. (I had a deduction that came out of my pay each week which I got back at the end of the year as vouchers) Its been over 3 months since I left and received my final pay along with my vouchers.

Any financial lawyers here who can enlighten me?

[FJRider]

If you know you DO owe them ... yes

[jasonu]

Stop in with 5 bucks worth of 5 cent pieces or even better 5 bucks worth of the smallest denomination postage stamps you can get if they are still legal tender. Don't forget to get a reciept incase their accountant makes a cock up and says you didn't pay.

[Tink]

I'm probably going too. I pass them on my way to work each day so its not sending me outta my way. I'm just curious.

When I left the supermarket I worked at, they over paid me $5 in Xmas club vouchers. (I had a deduction that came out of my pay each week which I got back at the end of the year as vouchers) Its been over 3 months since I left and received my final pay along with my vouchers.

Any financial lawyers here who can enlighten me?

If you spent the voucher I suggest you go in, get another voucher, and hand it back saying this is the voucher you owe them! If you have not spent the voucher then give it back, its the right thing to do... and as the dude above says, if you KNOW they over paid you, its only right to give it back.

BUT to me it seems pathetic, the person that stuffed up the vouchers is the one really at fault and you have left!!!! :drinkup:

[Virago]

I find it rather bizarre that an employer would be chasing this three months later. I'd phone and ask to speak to the manager about it.

[mattian]

Go in and pay them $6. then as you're walking out say.... "keep the change assholes".

Thats what Clint Eastwood would do. :laugh:

[SMOKEU]

Tell them to phuck off. What supermarket were you working at?

[Gareth123]

I am gonna pay them back. If I had to ride into Christchurch from Rangiora then I wouldn't but since I don't and I pass them each day its a bit stupid to not pay them.

I worked at Countdown. Most of the people I worked with were pretty awesome. The managers up in the office were pricks. Luckily for them its a nice person chasing me for the money:yes:

I might just do a Clint Eastwood on them, I'd feel pretty cool! Maybe a Rambo and just blow stuff up - I know that would make a lot of people happy :facepalm:

[kevfromcoro]

Go and pay it..
Shake there hands, and tell them how sorry you where for late payment...
On the way out.. find the most expensive item you can.. and piss all over it..
The wankers......

[Grumph]

You're too young to be racking up places you can't go back to.....

Pay it with a smile & they'll be happy to see you again.

Realise too that a number of the posters here would never have the guts to do what they're suggesting....

[trumpy]

I am stunned that any employer would ask for such a piffling amount back. I had a staff member leave owing us about ten bucks. It didn't take too many brains to figure out the cost of collection was greater than the amount owed. I could earn much more money for my company doing something more productive in the same given time. If they have managerial staff spending more than ten minutes and no paperwork to recover five bucks then they have too many pencil pushers.

[Flip]

I find it hard to believe they would ever chase up $5, it will cost them twenty times that to write you a letter.

You would be within your rights to ask them to justify this $5 debt in writing. Or just pay it and get them off your case.

[popelli]

either ignore it or ask for proper verification and proof of debt - it will be too much trouble for them to follow up on

for $5 they are not going to take you to court - it will cost them far too much time and effort

unless you are currently umemployed and need their reference for a job you have nothing to worry about

[Usarka]

Don't take my advice, but tell them to stick it up their arse, twist it so it corkscrews into their lower colon then remove with an alsatian. It'll cost them more time and money than it's worth to chase up, and at worst you get banned from the premises which you already hate. By the sounds you're not going to get a reference anyway.


Sorry, as I said ignore my advice. Just a bad experience my first night working at a supermarket when I was 16. Bunch of facists gave me grief for drinking a can of coke (that I paid for) after they'd made me work through my dinner break. Refer advice above.

[Woodman]

If you were overpaid then pay it, you never know when this sorta thing can turnround and bite you in the ass, although they should have settled it in your final pay.
Did you sign a termination agreement? If so there should have been something about all property etc has been returned or something like that.
I do have trouble wondering why they are bothering though, they must have fcuk all else to worry about.

Pay it move on.

[Gareth123]

Don't take my advice, but tell them to stick it up their arse, twist it so it corkscrews into their lower colon then remove with an alsatian. It'll cost them more time and money than it's worth to chase up, and at worst you get banned from the premises which you already hate. By the sounds you're not going to get a reference anyway.

Why don't you tell us how you really feel? :facepalm:

I don't hate them, I pity them. they're still stuck there and I'm working next door in a far better job. :sunny:

[p.dath]

It's no different to any other debt. If you know you owe it then you should pay it. It's called being decent. :-)

[R6_kid]

draw them a picture and tell them its worth more than $5 so you're giving them a good deal.

[Brian d marge]

Cant a cheque be written on any material ??? and egg for example??

Stephen

[sinfull]

Somebody must have a couple of twos and a one in old denomination to send this lad so he can go clear this OLD dept !

[ellipsis]

...honesty is one of those strange words that somehow has different avenues to follow, it seems...tell the truth as you see it to somebody and it is an unappreciated intrusion...tell the absolute truth sometimes and be branded a liar... tell yourself down the track in years to come that "I have lived my life as honestly as possible..." but little dishonest realities are overlooked, then, how honest has your life really been...they may be a huge money sucking, rip off corporation, and not worth shitting on, but as Grumph has mentioned, why do something that you have to live with for a long time to come...five bucks is a wank amount for the twats to chase, its also a wank amount to not give back with a smile, and it keeps your integrity intact... something I learned a long way back, was... "everything after, 'but', is bullshit...

[ynot slow]

If you know you owe it pay it back,but add a comment of I don't mind paying,but thought the times I started early or finished late by 10-15 mins meant I would've thought we're all square,but seems not here you are.

Personally I think the old swings and roundabouts works in cases of when you do work after or before normal seems to equal out at times.I don't mind doing measures/installs after hours,I just ask to finish earlier Fridays,my job means I can arrange that at times.

[Virago]

As mentioned before, it's incredible that they are chasing this - it's cost them more in administrative time and resources than the debt is worth. An indication that their intentions are more punative than pragmatic.

But as others have said, if you were overpaid, pay them back.

The best suggestion I've seen is to pay them $6.00, and tell them to keep the change...:yes:

[Gareth123]

Paid it back today when I went in to buy some food.:innocent:

The cash office lady apologised to me, said that it had come through from Aukland. Nothing they could do about it.

[Gareth123]

Cant a cheque be written on any material ??? and egg for example??

Stephen

I know you can do that in some countries. Not sure about NZ though.

[PrincessBandit]

Paid it back today when I went in to buy some food.:innocent:

The cash office lady apologised to me, said that it had come through from Aukland. Nothing they could do about it.

Good on you :niceone:. I can't believe you had to do it (regardless of it "being the decent thing to do"). Aucklanders are such pricks eh...(note, as a resident of Manukau I resist being called an Aucklander :msn-wink:)

[Big Dave]

Consider it $5 invested in your references.

[Tink]

Somebody must have a couple of twos and a one in old denomination to send this lad so he can go clear this OLD dept !

lol I have some two and one dollar notes... :)


Good on you :niceone:. I can't believe you had to do it (regardless of it "being the decent thing to do"). Aucklanders are such pricks eh...(note, as a resident of Manukau I resist being called an Aucklander :msn-wink:)

Heh try living 1 hour from Auckland lol.... oh ye you know that!!! ;) I rarely go into Auckland or if I do I pass through on my way to Puhoi (out of season of course)... and the roads are crap out this way... remind me why we pay rates.

Oh ye PB... lovely road works between waiuku and pukekohe, smashed fog light (arg) and chipped windscreen (just replaced it).... I am angry with whomever decides not to sweep the roads after the seal is down... and top that off even more crap on a bike!

Rant Over.... $5 seems minor lol GOOD ON YOU FOR SORTING IT OUT.:woohoo:

[pritch]

Paid it back today when I went in to buy some food.:innocent:


Good outcome. Reminds me of the words to a song:

"Be nice to the people you meet on the way up
You might meet up on the way down"

[sinfull]

lol I have some two and one dollar notes... :)



:

Burn em ! Worthless, just like your 10c 20c and 50c bits now ! Bit of tin painted up, you do know what the old 50c piece was worth in alloy aye ?

[Tink]

Burn em ! Worthless, just like your 10c 20c and 50c bits now ! Bit of tin painted up, you do know what the old 50c piece was worth in alloy aye ?

nope... but the notes, the kids look at them and say is that from the Monoply game!!!!!

[sinfull]

nope... but the notes, the kids look at them and say is that from the Monoply game!!!!!
Awww lol well that's all that matters then, but yeah nah fluctuates around the 50c mark and yeah the kids ARE right, all we gots now is play money, bet the 5ers don't even have the band of silver that used to make them worth five bucks aye ?

[Mom]

(note, as a resident of Manukau I resist being called an Aucklander :msn-wink:)

You think you have an issue with being called a jafa, try living where I do. Can not wait to see my new rate demand as a rate payer of the super shitty :shutup:

[Virago]

You think you have an issue with being called a jafa, try living where I do. Can not wait to see my new rate demand as a rate payer of the super shitty :shutup:

Super shitty...? Is that 'cos jafas are brown on the inside...?:innocent:

[sinfull]

Super shitty...? Is that 'cos jafas are brown on the inside...?:innocent:Like a news paper, black and white all over, but re(a)d through and through !