PDA

View Full Version : Vocab question and, like, whatever.



Big Dave
12th June 2007, 02:00
Flummoxed.

In this sentence:

'We’d take the Eucalypt, 'Saligna', timber born out of the toughness of the harsh Australian outback and transplanted to the bountiful North Island of New Zealand.'

Is it born or borne?
I meant created, but carried is also right....?

caesius
12th June 2007, 06:40
The child was "born" (emerged into life). The mother had "borne" (past participle of bear) her near the "bourn" (rivulet, also spelled "bourne").

So BORN looks like the winner.

sAsLEX
12th June 2007, 07:10
Both fit don't they?

riffer
12th June 2007, 09:06
Isn't it "born in" or "borne from"?

You could use both, but in this case it sounds like you want born.

Hitcher?

ManDownUnder
12th June 2007, 09:22
If I understand this correctly you could use both

"...born out of the toughness..."
or
"...borne of the toughness ..."

FWIW - I prefer the latter. It's "cleaner" to read.

Hitcher
12th June 2007, 09:23
Born is right. But a slightly flowery sentence, unless somebody wants the readers to get a hard-on for Aussie lumber.

MSTRS
12th June 2007, 09:35
Gum trees are tough. These trees do well in the North Island of New Zealand.
There....much better.

Pixie
12th June 2007, 09:57
Born is right. But a slightly flowery sentence, unless somebody wants the readers to get a hard-on for Aussie lumber.

The correct phrase is:....wants the readers to get wood for Aussie lumber.

Big Dave
12th June 2007, 10:58
But a slightly flowery sentence,


Shuuut uuuup! In advertising copy? No!

The paragraph concludes with: 'hard wood.'

Serious.

'Stock that has endured fierce drought and flooding rains for millennia, hard wood.'