Log in

View Full Version : Odd. Very odd.



Ixion
22nd February 2009, 20:46
A strange thing happened.

I was wobbling down to Paeroa on the bMW. Along the Miranda Road. Everything all running good. And I went over one of those little bridges they have, that had a drop off at the end, as they do, and came down fairly hard off it. No great speed cos I am very slow and never speed, just the speed that one does on that road, certainly not much more than 80mph.

Almost immediately I landed (within 2 or 3 seconds), I lost power. The loss quickly got worse, and the engine was barely running.

Spluttering , backfiring (exhaust and inlet). Dropped into first gear and was just able to keep headway on, heading for a farm gate about half a kilometre up the road. Engine would die "durrggggghhhh", splutter, cough, misfire, then pick up and rev fully for a few seconds (all this on full throttle). The bursts of revviness enabled me to creep along at maybe 10kph, kangaroo hopping like mad . Sometimes it would fall away and threaten to stall, but if I pulled in the clutch it would do the durrgghh, splutter, backfire, rev thing .

While this was happening I could hear a noise, not very loud , a bit like the chattering of a demented squirrel that's been on P for a week.

Just as I was nearing the farm gate, and preparing for the worst, I pulled in the clutch for another hop, when it spluutered, coughed, back fired ,revved and kept revving! Clean and free. Hallelujah.

And after that it was fine. Didn't miss a beat the rest of the way there, or back. Started no problem at Ngatea and Paeroa.

What could have caused that d'y think? Certainly I think it was fuelling (all electrics were fine)

Did the negative G over the bump send all the fuel (about 1/4 full) to the top of the tank, causing an airlock in the fuel pump? Seems rather, um, improbable.

Did the bump jolt loose a fuel pump connection, which magically jolted on again? Unlikely.

Did the bump shake loose some sort of fuel tank splooge that finally went away ?

Wasn't water in the fuel, bike was running absolutely fine down from Dorkland, and fine afterward.

Never done anything like it before. Looked the machine over at Ngatea, but couldn't see anything amiss (peered in the fuel tank too)

It's fuel injected. It's shaken my simple faith in FI.

McDuck
22nd February 2009, 20:51
A strange thing happened.

I was wobbling down to Paeroa on the bMW. Along the Miranda Road. Everything all running good. And I went over one of those little bridges they have, that had a drop off at the end, as they do, and came down fairly hard off it. No great speed cos I am very slow and never speed, just the speed that one does on that road, certainly not much more than 80mph.

Almost immediately I landed (within 2 or 3 seconds), I lost power. The loss quickly got worse, and the engine was barely running.

Spluttering , backfiring (exhaust and inlet). Dropped into first gear and was just able to keep headway on, heading for a farm gate about half a kilometre up the road. Engine would die "durrggggghhhh", splutter, cough, misfire, then pick up and rev fully for a few seconds (all this on full throttle). The bursts of revviness enabled me to creep along at maybe 10kph, kangaroo hopping like mad . Sometimes it would fall away and threaten to stall, but if I pulled in the clutch it would do the durrgghh, splutter, backfire, rev thing .

While this was happening I could hear a noise, not very loud , a bit like the chattering of a demented squirrel that's been on P for a week.

Just as I was nearing the farm gate, and preparing for the worst, I pulled in the clutch for another hop, when it spluutered, coughed, back fired ,revved and kept revving! Clean and free. Hallelujah.

And after that it was fine. Didn't miss a beat the rest of the way there, or back. Started no problem at Ngatea and Paeroa.

What could have caused that d'y think? Certainly I think it was fuelling (all electrics were fine)

Did the negative G over the bump send all the fuel (about 1/4 full) to the top of the tank, causing an airlock in the fuel pump? Seems rather, um, improbable.

Did the bump jolt loose a fuel pump connection, which magically jolted on again? Unlikely.

Did the bump shake loose some sort of fuel tank splooge that finally went away ?

Wasn't water in the fuel, bike was running absolutely fine down from Dorkland, and fine afterward.

Never done anything like it before. Looked the machine over at Ngatea, but couldn't see anything amiss (peered in the fuel tank too)

It's fuel injected. It's shaken my simple faith in FI.


It could be water, if the inlet is above the tank bottom the fuel would sit on the water. When it went over the bump it flicked the hole lot up and the inlet sucked in a little water?

3umph
22nd February 2009, 20:59
A strange thing happened.

I was wobbling down to Paeroa on the bMW. Along the Miranda Road. Everything all running good. And I went over one of those little bridges they have, that had a drop off at the end, as they do, and came down fairly hard off it. No great speed cos I am very slow and never speed, just the speed that one does on that road, certainly not much more than 80mph.

Almost immediately I landed (within 2 or 3 seconds), I lost power. The loss quickly got worse, and the engine was barely running.

Spluttering , backfiring (exhaust and inlet). Dropped into first gear and was just able to keep headway on, heading for a farm gate about half a kilometre up the road. Engine would die "durrggggghhhh", splutter, cough, misfire, then pick up and rev fully for a few seconds (all this on full throttle). The bursts of revviness enabled me to creep along at maybe 10kph, kangaroo hopping like mad . Sometimes it would fall away and threaten to stall, but if I pulled in the clutch it would do the durrgghh, splutter, backfire, rev thing .

While this was happening I could hear a noise, not very loud , a bit like the chattering of a demented squirrel that's been on P for a week.

Just as I was nearing the farm gate, and preparing for the worst, I pulled in the clutch for another hop, when it spluutered, coughed, back fired ,revved and kept revving! Clean and free. Hallelujah.

And after that it was fine. Didn't miss a beat the rest of the way there, or back. Started no problem at Ngatea and Paeroa.

What could have caused that d'y think? Certainly I think it was fuelling (all electrics were fine)

Did the negative G over the bump send all the fuel (about 1/4 full) to the top of the tank, causing an airlock in the fuel pump? Seems rather, um, improbable.

Did the bump jolt loose a fuel pump connection, which magically jolted on again? Unlikely.

Did the bump shake loose some sort of fuel tank splooge that finally went away ?

Wasn't water in the fuel, bike was running absolutely fine down from Dorkland, and fine afterward.

Never done anything like it before. Looked the machine over at Ngatea, but couldn't see anything amiss (peered in the fuel tank too)

It's fuel injected. It's shaken my simple faith in FI.

Could it of been the stand partly down??? don't know your bike but if it has a cut off switch on the stand when in gear this could of been on the brink of flicking on and off but as you slowed it went back into place and took off like normal...

just an idea

Ixion
22nd February 2009, 21:02
Could it of been the stand partly down??? don't know your bike but if it has a cut off switch on the stand when in gear this could of been on the brink of flicking on and off but as you slowed it went back into place and took off like normal...

just an idea

No stand cut off. No safety type switches at all.

smoky
22nd February 2009, 21:05
I had a V twin 800 - the same thing happened as you described, checked everything, found nothing
It happened again and I tried to crawl along home as you described - occasionally it would run OK and I'd make some distance - I should of stopped riding it;
Turns out it was an exhaust flange leak where it bolts onto the motor. trying to keep riding it resulted in a burnt valve?
I know it sounds strange and unrelated, but actually when you think it thru; it was upsetting the fuel scavenging dynamics of one of the cylinders and thus running too lean, also upsetting the balance between the two carbs and messing with the fuel supply to the second cylinder.
It's a long shot but check your exhaust.

I had a similar thing on another bike, and it turned out to be the gradual breakdown of the CDI unit.

Ixion
22nd February 2009, 21:26
FI not carbs. And such a dereliction would (a) not be likely to start instantly and (b) be even less likely to completly cure itself instantly.

It went from running absolutely fine, to durgggh spluuter cough rev durrgh etc in a couple of seconds. And when it cleared it went from durggh etc to running absolutely fine within a second

I suspect (without evidence) that the squirrel chattering was the fuel pump (inside the tank), sucking air. I think it progressively went from three cylinders to two to one to none, then randomly played the combinations of 0 1 2 and 3 . The moments when 3 were running being the revvy moments. Then all three climbed back aboard and all was well.

I can think of lots of reasons for such a problem. I can think of far fewer that will completly cure themselves after a few seconds , and which are precipitated by a bad bump (though the bump may be coincidental of course) .

Madness
22nd February 2009, 21:29
http://www.kiwibiker.co.nz/forums/showthread.php?t=93075

McDuck
22nd February 2009, 21:34
My next guess is there is a sencer having a sulk which it got over after a min or two...

Motu
22nd February 2009, 21:39
Do they have a swirl pot? Where the returning fuel is fed to keep the level on the suction side of the pump high.Having the swirl pot depleted of fuel would cause starvation,until it returned to a normal level,and then running perfectly again.To cause this sort of fuel starvation you would need some sort of air leak at the suction side of the pump.

What sort of air flow meter do they use? Check the intake boot.

TLDV8
22nd February 2009, 21:42
Sounds like cavitation of the shuttlecock then the pump hyperventilated.

smoky
22nd February 2009, 21:51
Sounds like cavitation of the shuttlecock then the pump hyperventilated.

Or hyperventilation pump of your cock while cavitating the shuttle

Ixion
22nd February 2009, 22:03
No swirl pot. The airflow meter is a vane type, same as BMW cars.

One possibility is that BMW have a trick to save fuel. If the computer detects that the throttle position sensor switch shows a fully closed throttle, but revs are greater than 2500 (ie, you are on the overrun) , it cuts off the fuel . The bump could have deranged the TPS switch temporarily causing the computer to shut off the fuel whenever the revs exceeded 2500. Maybe. Perhaps. Or not. Too much black magic here. Maybe I might resign from SAMAC (the Society for the Abolition of that Monstrous Abomination the Carburettor. )

It wasn't a very big bump , though.

Motu
22nd February 2009, 22:40
The vane type is a mechanical device,unlike the later more esoteric hocus pocus stuff.They give a bit of trouble in cars,although given how many and how old,failures wouldn't blip any Bosch radar.A motorcycle is a much harsher enviroment....but you should have your finger on the pulse of K75 air flow meter problems.

False air.....or false fuel.It wasn't monitoring one or the other - but thought it was.

Ixion
22nd February 2009, 22:53
There's a bit of history of the AFM needing adjustment , to eliminate black smoke. But i've not encountered any report of complete failure.

A third suspect is fuel flow somehow. Let the electronic whizzies think what they may, if there is no fuel , or the pump won't pump it, strange things will happen. . The whizzies calculate how long and when to open the injectors. But they blithely assume that there will be petrol in the line to inject.

The deranged squirrel rattle sounded very like a pump cavitating. No, I don't know why it would do that. The initial effect was exactly like running out of fuel on an FI engine - in fact for a moment I thought I had.

McDuck
23rd February 2009, 06:38
There's a bit of history of the AFM needing adjustment , to eliminate black smoke. But i've not encountered any report of complete failure.

A third suspect is fuel flow somehow. Let the electronic whizzies think what they may, if there is no fuel , or the pump won't pump it, strange things will happen. . The whizzies calculate how long and when to open the injectors. But they blithely assume that there will be petrol in the line to inject.

The deranged squirrel rattle sounded very like a pump cavitating. No, I don't know why it would do that. The initial effect was exactly like running out of fuel on an FI engine - in fact for a moment I thought I had.

Maby go back to the spot and see if you can do it again....

Mc TOOL
23rd February 2009, 08:42
We had a bit of fun with the Mrs's MR2 , almost exactly as you describe ( no squirrels ) turned out that the wiring harness retainer clips on 2 of the injector nozzles had broken and the slightest touch to the harness would cause the loss of one or two cylinders

sinfull
23rd February 2009, 09:02
Far too simple, but i'd go check the battery terminals !

martybabe
23rd February 2009, 09:16
I'd go for the Fuel cack disturbance, rust, water, unspecified debris. Your neg G could possibly have caused the fuel pump to suck in any of the above or even momentarily, just air. It would fit with the cavitation noises and the later return to full function. Did you have much fuel or just swillings?

Good luck anyway mate, mysterious faults are a bastard.

Ixion
23rd February 2009, 10:19
Maby go back to the spot and see if you can do it again....

I did , more or less. Rode back home on the same road, same bridge, same speeds , no problems at all.

I would be quite happy to add it to the long list of WIS (Weird Inexplicable Shit) that I have accumulated over the years, and put it down to quantum, or sunspots. Just so long as it is not the first harbinger of Infuriating Shit that Gets Steady Worse until it finally leaves me stranded 50 Miles from WopWop, at night, in the rain.

SPman
23rd February 2009, 13:49
Stick some Amals on it!
Should fix it in a jiffy!

The Pastor
23rd February 2009, 15:41
Sounds like a shit modern bike to me ;)

xwhatsit
23rd February 2009, 15:46
Stick some Amals on it!
Should fix it in a jiffy!
Fix what? Its ability to idle?

Ixion
23rd February 2009, 16:09
Amal GPs FTW

smoky
23rd February 2009, 16:25
Amal GPs FTW

Is it me or what? but some posts just look like a bunch of letters to me!
Now days people seem able to write a whole sentance without actually using a real word

Whats Amal? I take it it's not the Shi'a political movement founded by Musa al-Sadr but rather a type of carburetor!
Gps is what? the Moto GP or a Gobal positioning (little) system
And FTW? I see it around a bit, but I did find this link http://ftwtattoo.com/ to FTW tattoo artists

So to interpret your sentence 'Amal GPs FTW', it would be a coded message for;
'The Shi'a Gorillas GPS location is a Tattoo shop in Oakland California'


Am I right - do I get a prise?????

Ixion
23rd February 2009, 16:45
Good lord dude, what stone have you been hiding under ?

You can't be old, or you would know what an Amal was. But you can't be young, or you would know what FTW was.

The Amal carburettor , the finest product of the proud Briddish scrap iron industry. The GP model was a thing of , well it was, um, actually it was a problematic pain in the arse. No idle circuit at all, almost impossible to start and if you did you had to keep blipping the bike like mad cos otherwise it cut out. But the street cred was enormous. Sort of like modern sprotsbikes , I guess.

And FTW means, well, it means FTW . For the Win maybe? But it doesn't have to mean anything, it just means FTW. Godda keep up with the times, eh.

Maha
23rd February 2009, 16:52
I did , more or less. Rode back home on the same road, same bridge, same speeds , no problems at all.

I would be quite happy to add it to the long list of WIS (Weird Inexplicable Shit) that I have accumulated over the years, and put it down to quantum, or sunspots. Just so long as it is not the first harbinger of Infuriating Shit that Gets Steady Worse until it finally leaves me stranded 50 Miles from WopWop, at night, in the rain.


There is a real nice Pub at WopWop...they serve a delish feed of Satay Butter Chicken blended with guinea fowl liver...its ok until the next morning.

MSTRS
23rd February 2009, 16:53
Amals schamals...you need to adapt some downdraft Webbers. http://fortmyers.craigslist.org/mcy/1043983138.html
Extra horsies too....