'He killed girlfriend due to emotional pain', court told

**puddytat** · 25th June 2009, 18:59

Man,.. the planets full & this fucker doesnt deserve the space he takes up, off with his head!!
You cant rationalise his behaviour, why bother?. Anyway you look at it he was so way out of line that he fell off the edge.
He will now cost us millions.....
Fucker.

**dave_a** · 25th June 2009, 20:51

This shit makes me fucking sick, I hope he gets arse rapped and beaten daily in prison

**short-circuit** · 25th June 2009, 21:00

Originally Posted by dave_a

I hope he gets arse rapped and beaten daily in prison

What do you suggest his arse should be "rapped" with?

**Ragingrob** · 25th June 2009, 21:20

Originally Posted by short-circuit

What do you suggest his arse should be "rapped" with?

Eminem

**dave_a** · 25th June 2009, 21:43

Originally Posted by short-circuit

What do you suggest his arse should be "rapped" with?

big throbbing schlong

**scumdog** · 25th June 2009, 21:46

Originally Posted by Ragingrob

Eminem

Is that a sort of enema???

**Ragingrob** · 25th June 2009, 21:57

Originally Posted by scumdog

Is that a sort of enema???

Na they're little candy covered chocolates

**sinfull** · 25th June 2009, 22:07

erectile disfunction = Claytons sex

**Dirty_Harri** · 25th June 2009, 22:33

Originally Posted by dave_a

This shit makes me fucking sick, I hope he gets arse raped and beaten daily in prison

I could not have said it better Dave.

Don't worry, this sick f*ck will get his.

**Clockwork** · 26th June 2009, 11:32

Originally Posted by jrandom

Here's the NZ Herald article.

Given the details available, what's all y'all's take on the apparent defence of reduced responsibility due to emotional pain making him lose self-control?

Me, I'd acquit him. There are quite a few bitches out there that need a good stabbing, and reading between the lines, I'd say he got himself one.

Chances are he's saved dozens of other guys a broken heart in the future.

Now, maybe he shouldn't get a medal, exactly, but I'd certainly say it's not a case of cold-blooded murder.

So.

Can emotional pain ever form justifiable provocation for murder?

Does cruelly driving someone to that state of mind make a murder victim someone that the world is better off without?

Your thoughts please, ladies and gentlemen.

Appologies if I'm mistaken but weren't you on the "Hang 'im by the balls" side of the argument when TV got into similar bother last year?

**Headbanger** · 26th June 2009, 11:41

He was caught in the act, he has admitted causing her death, Why the hell is there a defence?

They should send everyone home, allocate 4 minutes to decide how soon they can execute him, and then bury a bullet in his skull.

Could have it all sorted for a couple of hundred bucks.

**ynot slow** · 26th June 2009, 16:23

Originally Posted by Headbanger

He was caught in the act, he has admitted causing her death, Why the hell is there a defence?

They should send everyone home, allocate 4 minutes to decide how soon they can execute him, and then bury a bullet in his skull.

Could have it all sorted for a couple of hundred bucks.

The tosser admits to manslaughter due to lighter sentance,but prosecution want murder.

To say he had impotence problems with her what a poofter,he'll have fun in jail,as getting it up will be least of his worries,good riddence.

**Patrick** · 26th June 2009, 17:05

Originally Posted by ynot slow

The tosser admits to manslaughter due to lighter sentance,but prosecution want murder.

To say he had impotence problems with her what a poofter,he'll have fun in jail,as getting it up will be least of his worries,good riddence.

Still life for Mans laughter.....

He will make perfect jail bait... he can't get hard so he won't be accused of being a poof while being arse fucked by Bubba then...???