
Originally Posted by
Sketchy_Racer
I am doing the latter and obviously I am biased, but the 'pen pusher' engineers are the type of people with infinite knowledge about design and materials etc, but have no grasp on how things work in the real world.
There is a grain of truth in what you say but it is still a very very broad generalisation.
I am a degree qualified engineer and there was a time when I'll bet I could have given you a really good run for your money with a lathe, milling machine or welder.
Don't forget either, that every major project you see out there, from a bridge to an oil refinery, has a professional engineer at the helm. Most of these projects seem to work OK afterwards and so some of those engineers must have some grip on reality and how the world works.
The most rewarding jobs I have ever done, started with an open piece of land and finished with a working factory. I had to understand it all, from laying the drains to programming the PLC's. You just don't get that variety in the workshop. (Note that I said "understand", not "do".)
The sense of achievement depends entirely on the individual however. It's not necessarily related to the job and I support your suggestion about work experience BTW.
There is no substitute for experience I agree, but when it goes hand in hand with knowledge, there are no limits.
Professional engineers have made a bigger contribution to improvements in our living standards than any other group and that's a measureable fact, not just an opinion. Their influence reaches into many, many other professions. I recall an opthalmologist who had just completed a corneal transplant on a friend of mine telling us it all came down to the engineer who designed his tools, that made it possible.
The point of this rave is that I think that you do the OP a disservice in trying to dissuade him from the professional path. My own experience was that I didn't realise how many doors it opens until after I had the qualification (which takes 4 years not 3 incidentally).
I may not be as good as I once was, but I'm as good once as I always was.
Bookmarks