Who else thought Star Wars 3 sucked? (SPOILER: DONT READ UNLESS SEEN!!)

[Sutage]

Yeh so watched star wars III last night.

Thought it was absoulutely totally crap. The acting of Obeone(sp?) made me want to cry. God, all the actors were so shit its unbelievable where do they find these ppl? Yoda annoyed the shit out of me with his ridiclous talknig technique, in the first one of the new ones when hes in it it makes sense but in the 3rd one jesus its just annoying
the robot clone bad guy things were stupid and the voices were annoying
the trade federation aliens sounded like terrible accented single digit IQ morons, who should all be shot
temurea morrison was cheesy as hell, he should stick to wife beating as he does in once were warriors where he was actually good and convincing of his role
the darth vader breathing scene was crap too, they coulda made it way better
whats with the cheesy changes to the next scene? sure having those shitty changes were ok in the 70s/80s or when you make a shit movie of your vacation in Windows Movie Maker but in a professional film? learn to use graphic match and fades and all that crap
the script was cheesy as hell, the senator "sith lord" guy should not to try look angry or evil, he should just stick to looking old or wahtever, where do they find these people?
what was with R2D2 and the cheesy beeps he made every time? everyone who made this movie should be forced to make bollywood movies, because then the ppl watchnig them are going to expect they are shit
some of the special effects were cool though
man, what a waste of time, im gonna read the books because the storyline is kickass, just the director needs to stick his 50million dollar budget up his ass
thats all
-Richard

[NhuanH]

much anger I sense in you.

Anger leads to fear, fear leads to the dark side.

Use the force Rich, use the force

[FROSTY:Me]

the filum you need to study young rich. feel the power feel the force nahh fuck that feel the missing moolah from ya pocket

[James Deuce]

Ever heard of the willing suspension of disbelief?

Relax young Jedi and let the universe fill you with its wonders.

[vifferman]

I haven't seen it, but reading various comments (from all the movies, not just this one) the problem is that George Lucas is very much a one-man band, and writes the screenplay, script, directs, etc. etc., and doesn't allow the actors to deviate from the script. Even very experienced and highly talented ones like Alec Guiness were told off when they said, "Hey George - this doesn't work; how about we do such-and-such instead?", which is normal for movies, and good directors will usually consider such input. However George insisted that the actors do it his way, as he knew best. I've read several comments from people like Carrie Fisher, Mark Hamill, Liam Neeson, Alec Guiness, Harrison Ford, etc., who said the script really sucked, but they had to stick with it. That's why it ends up looking like they are crap actors, but at least they got paid very well for it.

[Madguitarist!]

Much disturbance in the force I feel, much anger young sutage padawan has..
More to it then just missing moolahs I believe......
Anger DOES lead to the dark side, and FEAR is a powerful tool for the Sith Lord...
Control your emotions, you must.......
Or betray you, your thoughts will!



Sorry Richard, just had to rub it in!
You gotta understand that this is the last episode of an epic for a generation...(like me )...... Yes it was cheesy, Yes the script was stupid at times, Yes the acting could be better, and YES you could think of it as a waste of time/money.... BUT.... I LOVED IT!
It completes the 'circle or life' for the Star Wars franchise and having grown up with it I appreciate the 'motif' of them cheesy scene changes, intro, etc... coz that was there from the first episode... in fact watching it last nite it really brought me back to the 1st time I saw Star Wars (which was WAAAY b4 your time ) becoz of those cheesy details!

So for what it's worth, I think it ROCKS!

[Sniper]

Hmmmmm, much annoyance and misunderstanding I sense in him. This small padowan, not understanding of the force is he

[Motoracer]

There are always varrying opinions. I loved it and I wasn't really much of huge starwars fan before that either.


Loved Portmans acting, though I could be biased...

[Ramius]

Yes, anger is an opinion based on the film. However, your expectations are way too high if you expected anything more than has been previously released. Learn from your anger and channel it in the more appropriate movies.

PS I did not like this as much as I could.

[vifferman]

Loved Portmans acting, though I could be biased...

Waddabout now that she's shaved her head? :spudwhat:

[750Y]

i was recently set straight by a trekky after commenting that i'd only seen the first 2 (star wars & battlestar galactica!) lol.

[Motoracer]

Waddabout now that she's shaved her head? :spudwhat:

Well honestly she isn't very attractive with the shaved head, but it's not a permanent look. Besides what makes her special hasn't got much to do with the looks anyway. There are a lot of pretty girls around. Who she is as a person, from what I've read, is really what impressed me.

[bugjuice]

those comments you made sound almost like you haven't seen the previous star wars movies.. I'm no fanatic by any means, really not fussed about them, but I can appreciate the effort into the series of films over the years. Like the fading effects you mention. This is the 3rd movie, the 4th, 5th and 6th were the first out, so they can't go too overboard (which they have) with fades etc, else when you watch it in line, it won't match. I doubt it's gonna anyway, but that was the thinking of it..

[Zed]

Yeh so watched star wars III last night.

Thought it was absoulutely totally crap.

Well you're entitled to your little rave even if it is a load of codswallop!

So tell me Sutage, what did you think of "Spaceballs" then??

[James Deuce]

Loved Portmans acting, though I could be biased...

I did too - her's was the one character that evidenced emotional depth. I actually believed that crappy line, "Anakin, you're breaking my heart." You could hear it go, "twangg."

Though having said that Ewan's "stiff-upper-lip" Obi Wan was very true to mid-20th century British male norms.