Woman brutally attacked

[avgas]

I still like the idea of a some kind of prison island.
I wonder how much someone would enjoy life after they had to fight for it.
Like Banditbandit said, keep em there until their 40's.
Then offer them a simple job and some something to live for.

Would it work?

[Duke girl]

Bloody low life thugs who deserve to rott in Hell. How would they feel if that happened to their own, eg: Sister, Mother, Aunty or girlfriend.
Tough guys they think they are but they are actually Mongrels and here's hoping that 1 day it happenes to them Big Time.

[Taz]

From my experience working with youth offenders I believe they would probably not be afraid of your whipping at all, and have probably had that and much worse in their life already. I know you all think that beating someone to within an inch of their life will teach them that beating someone to within an inch of their life is wrong, but I suggest they have already been taught that it is an acceptable way to get what you want. None of the violent youth offenders that I see grew up in 'time out' families. I totally understand your anger, but as the saying goes "for every complex problem there is a simple solution, and it's wrong".

Simple solution - Put them to death. Problem solved.