Originally Posted by
HenryDorsetCase
Well. theres a can o'worms (TM)
The Nazis would say "everyone but the farmers"
Labour would say "everyone"
But "ethical" rights to access? That's the point of a democracy innit? I read a very interesting piece over the weekend about why we should be taxing every profit everywhere. Including the sale of the family home (which even the Nazis havent touched with their stupid capital gains tax by stealth).
Point or otherwise the effect of our particular democracy is to tax by consensus. Nothing about that infers ethical behaviour. It's simply an exercise in which group gets to steal which other group's income in order to give it to which other group. In fact the ethics aren't all that difficult to establish via the catch-all: is the tax willingly paid?
The answer is almost always: "depends on what you're spending it on". Which is why it's interesting to see public focus almost exclusively on the personalities involved, rather than the policy.
I, along with most Nazis have no problem with taxing profit, it's vaguely aligned with the cost of supplying the tools that make it possible. And, (bonus point, but irrelevant) roughly matches the ability to pay it. Neither of which make it ethical, but it's rather a lot less larcenous than the "see money: tax money" approach offered elsewhere.
I don't have a problem with Labour's "everyone", either. Even at a level endured by most Scandinavial economies. As long as the benefits are shared across the board as those countries mostly manage them, none of this working for someone else's family bullshit. Getting taxed to buggery AND not being eligible for cheap access to the very services those taxes pay for is what I believe is called "double dipping".
I'm not up on the stealthy CG thing, who are they suggesting is going to calculate what represents "profit" wrt moneys resulting from sale of homes? 'Cause answers along the lines of : "this special govt entity right here" will result in absolute pandemonium.
Go soothingly on the grease mud, as there lurks the skid demon
Bookmarks