I've got 3 kids and they come with a bunch of preset behaviours, and they are all very different. Nurture has very little to do with personality, despite what self aggrandising parenting "experts" will tell you.
Values can only be imparted by example, and punishment can only be effective if it is used rarely and the consequences are both dire, and consistently enforced. As you've rightly pointed out Dafe, the most effective parenting tool has been removed from the arsenal, but most people (children are people too), once they have use of the tools of reasoning and imagination, don't do stupid shit that hurts other people.
This event is a rare one. It is not undertaken by every person, it isn't representative of the broader aspects of human social cooperation. They were 13 and 15. Most Social Sciences professionals believe that the dawn of reason arrives at about 4 on average. I don't see bad parenting (if indeed you could define their parents as "bad") as the sole reason, or maybe not even a contributing factor, that these two ignoramuses felt they could perform a criminal act with impunity.
For some reason that escapes me, I see a broader attitude to family that doesn't reflect how the world works anymore in action that allows everyone else to pass judgement on two people (the parents) from afar, with no understanding of their situation at all. And no desire to understand it.
"It's the parents fault", "I blame the family". Come on guys, they were 13 and 15. It is their own "fault". Instead of being made to clean it up and then dragged home by a beat cop to be humiliated in front of their parents who would then provide their own relevant form of punishment, every voter out there has allowed proven tools to be removed from the parenting arsenal. Youth Aid can bleat at the 13 year old all they want. They have little power to do anything to the little sod. The best thing that could happen to him is that the 15 year old goes away for a bit of corrective therapy.
It's really easy to blame the parents. These two kids were old enough to know better. There are more people than just parents involved in imparting values to children. Extended family, schools, media, friends and their families, and the attitudes of Government in general. If that doesn't work, then you've obviously got a couple of dickheads.
Bookmarks