RockStar Supernova

[Maha]

Cant really see a chick fronting the band...nothing against the idea, its just that the guys would rather the frontman to pull chick's.....not guys...
And Dilana/Storm would pull the kinda chicks that aint into men, and Tommy would miss out.....
So........ Lukas has the persona and look and voice and lovely eyes (not my observation btw) and Magni has a great voice range, where as Toby?..dont know....Jury still out on that one

[placidfemme]

Cant really see a chick fronting the band...nothing against the idea, its just that the guys would rather the frontman to pull chick's.....not guys...
And Dilana/Storm would pull the kinda chicks that aint into men, and Tommy would miss out.....
So........ Lukas has the persona and look and voice and lovely eyes (not my observation btw) and Magni has a great voice range, where as Toby?..dont know....Jury still out on that one

Toby to me... is too much of a "pretty boy". He's got that preppy "I'm so hot" look and attitude that annoys me...

I agree that a man would be best to front the band... and Magni is the best option...

*still cheering for Dilana though*

[Maha]

Yeah Lucas is not suited at all for this type of band... I also think that the songs that "Supernova" have sung so far suck... By what I've heard I won't be buying the album...

Dilana actually has done pretty well on her solar career... She's released two CD's already I believe under the name "Dilana Smith"

Dilana is a mix of....Stevie nicks (the look).... Kate Bush (flity/barefoot/prancey).....Marian Faithfull (voice).... all good on their own, but mixed together?..... NA!....
I like peanut butter and Banana's....but not together....

[Joni]

Dilana is from Johannesburg... say no more

[Beemer]

I enjoyed the INXS one because I could relate to the music and there were some damn good singers on the show, but I haven't bothered watching this series. I catch the end of it sometimes when I change channels and I heard a few of them last week. I'm sorry, but apart from being one of the scariest sheilas I've ever seen, in my opinion that Dilana can't sing! Screeching the words of a song is NOT singing!

One of the guys I heard wasn't bad but all the women were crap!

[Patrick]

Dilana and Magni to share the win?????

[placidfemme]

Dilana and Magni to share the win?????

lol would be.... interesting to say the least... might actually make Supernova something worth listening too....

[skelstar]

Well since no-one was going to answer my question I went and found out for my self...heres the elimination synopsis from the official site:

Week 9 Elimination Recap

Ryan Star Goes Home

Performances have become so stellar on "Rock Star" that elimination is proving to be tougher and tougher each week. It now comes down to one thing--who is the best fit?

To find the lucky Rocker, Supernova will be testing how well each gels with the band. After tonight's elimination, the remaining five will be engaging in a songwriting clinic where Gilby announced he would personally help each write a new Supernova track. The Rockers were stoked.

Super-stoked was Lukas, who was asked to front Supernova for their newest song "It's On." Singing with power and intensity, he worked the crowd into a frenzy. Realizing that the gauntlet had now been thrown, his fellow Rockers appeared a little worried by his effortless bravura performance.

If Toby was worried, he didn't show it during tonight's encore. The affable Aussie performed another rousing version of Billy Idol's "Rebel Yell," singing, screaming and jumping into the delighted audience.

And then, the bottom three. With only six Rockers left, some would experience their initial moment of possible elimination. The first to stand up were Storm, Ryan and Lukas. As more votes came in throughout the night, the next at risk Rockers identified were Toby and Dilana. Lukas and Dilana had never felt this kind of heat before. Magni, true to his song from last night ("I Alone") was the only Rocker completely safe from elimination. Tommy exclaimed, "They're having one hell of a party in Iceland right now!"

The party ended, however, when the bottom three were announced. A disappointed Ryan was first. Wishing to rock it harder for Supernova, he chose The Who's anthem "Baba O' Riley." Hoping to amp up his stage presence, the usually sensitive Rocker broke open a bottle of champagne and sprayed it on the audience. He definitely wanted to save himself. Could he?

Storm was the second Rocker announced. Ever confident, she wasn't fazed by it and instead, approached her place in the danger zone as a chance to show more of what she's made of. With The Beatles' "Helter Skelter," a tune she claimed was one of the first punk rock songs ever written, Storm was vocally impressive but also down and dirty. She even sat on Tommy's lap.

The shocker was Dilana. The consistently exemplary Rocker had gone through something of a personal beating and her place in the bottom three must have hit home. Still, she maintained an aggressive sense of humor by singing The Talking Head's "Psycho Killer" dedicated, in part, to herself. Dilana's been a favorite this season, but after this performance, would she maintain that position?

The answer was up to Supernova. All three Rockers stood nervously as Gilby assessed their strengths and weaknesses before Tommy wielded the axe. Addressing Ryan, Tommy said, "You're probably the only cat who has come the farthest but... you're the next to go." The New York Rocker, whom Dave dubbed "The Dark Horse", was visibly upset. After thanking Dave for his support, the jilted Ryan told Supernova that he was sorry they'd be missing an opportunity to make music with him.

So who will get the opportunity? With five Rockers left, "It's On!"

[placidfemme]

Well since no-one was going to answer my question I went and found out for my self...heres the elimination synopsis from the official site:

Sorry man... I missed your question... yeah it was Ryan Star...

Even though he has grown a huge amoutn since the first episode he's gone... He did have a great voice... but all his song choices involved the piano/keyboard which is in my opinion why they sent him home... his "style" is just not rock enough...

so goodbye to the "Darkhorse"... I'm sure he'll have an awesome solar career anyway...

[skelstar]

No worries...here's my take:

I always thought Ryan Star (no relation) looked real awkward...he'd ham-it up for the band but would look completely out of place.

Lucas looks ambivalent but Ive always quite liked him...but looks wrong for the band.

Ms Large looks hot but is out of her league, but has a fantastic voice IMHO.

I thought Magni was super weak in his first coupla weeks. His performances are great, but seems a little too nice and family oriented to be badass.

Toby looks great (I guess) but is a bit weak in his performances. Would be great fronting a band in Courtney Pl on a Friday night, but can you see him infront of Tommy bashing the drums like he does? ...or Gilby dragging his guitar around?

Dilana - hmmm....great attitude (scripted falling out?) and looks awesome, but cant see a chick fronting their band. Can you?

[Joni]

Can you?

Yes....

[skelstar]

Yes....

I should have been more specific...can you objectively?

[Swoop]

Dilana is from Johannesburg... say no more

So she will hold them up at gunpoint to steal their wallet and car???

[Hitcher]

Magni. For no other reason than he doesn't have the totally cliched tatts and piercings. Or hair.

[Mom]

No worries...here's my take:
Dilana - hmmm....great attitude (scripted falling out?) and looks awesome, but cant see a chick fronting their band. Can you?

Dilana for me is great, and even quite attractive without the face bling..but, fronting the band........

Magni. For no other reason than he doesn't have the totally cliched tatts and piercings. Or hair.

Probably will get there, the other members of super nova are not raging youths anymore, family is important to them I am sure.........bear in mind public persona sells.......the image they want is hard core.......bet they are a bunch of softies underneath.