Not really. That's a common misconception about heavier genres of contemporary music. Yes they explore dark themes, no the lyrics aren't on the surface bright and uplifting. But for the fans of this music, listening to it can be a very visceral and cathartic experience where they can connect with their emotions and find inspiration, hope and fellowship from the music through the voice of the band and singer.
Each of us have, to a greater or lesser extent, certain pressures stresses and hurts in our lives. A lot of people bottle these up or try to suppress them with alcohol and/or drugs. Part of the enjoyment of listening to, watching live or even performing in a heavy metal band is to expunge these demons and revel in the sweaty, cathartic and very physical environment of the mosh-pit.
In my opinion the mosh-pit is a modern incarnation of a battle-field, where young men can unleash all their frustrations in a peer-controlled environment. Amped-up and emboldened by the band, these guys (and girls) can jump around, arms flailing, charging into each other with joyous abandon. If someone falls down, an anonymous hand will immediately grasp them by the wrist to pull them back up again. If you ever want to see a bunch of really happy young guys, go and watch a mosh-pit in action. I call it good natured violence - it has all the appearances of an all out brawl, with none of the adherent injuries or hatred of a real fight. In this sense it can be a very healthy enviroment to let off steam.
These are just some of the themes inherent with this genre of music, and it's got me thinking I'd like to write a bit more about them, maybe as part of a larger blog in an appropriate forum.
Bookmarks