Guilty or innocent.

[The Pastor]

Is old david bane guilty or innocent,


I know there are threads on this, but as far as I know, there are no polls.


What do ya think?

[JimO]

far to many loose ends for him to be found guilty....fathers incest, glasses lense etc

[James Deuce]

Sigh. There's always one.

[Grahameeboy]

Does seem that an injustice has been done, however, at end of day who really knows..................hopefully for all involved it will sort itself out..I guess if the matter is being re-visited there are some unanswered questions.

[The Pastor]

all I know is hes going to get a MASSIVE compo payout!

[ManDownUnder]

Let the uninformed masses vote. Let's face it - who out there knows all the relevant facts.

Or perhaps - (s)he with all the facts should simply speak! It'd save a lot of time and heartache.

[Quartermile]

I think hes Guilty, but thinkiong about that case with that lady who was jailed for killing her son on 20/20 last week maybe hes not,

Don't feel too strong on the subject as I don't know all the facts.

[The Pastor]

since when has KB ever been about making informed discions based on facts? Let the good times roll and vote what you think, sorta like a gamble - time will tell who was right.

[yod]

far to many loose ends for him to be found guilty....fathers incest, glasses lense etc

which doesnt mean he IS innocent...it just means you think the jury should have found reasonable doubt....yes?

[Jantar]

I have voted Guilty on this poll, becasue that is what I believe.

If I was on a jury I would have to vote Not Guilty, because there isn't sufficient evidence to say Guilty beyond reasonable doubt, and because there is an equal possibility that it was Robin Bain who committed the crime.

[Mr. Peanut]

He's not going to re-offend if he does get out. And his family is dead.

What concern is it of the (largely uninformed) public?

[Mom]

Need to add a "have no idea/fixed opinion/need to hear all the facts/ignore the spin" option I vote that way..........good poll though!

[candor]

Sorry - these KB pols never seem to have the option I want.

Have to say - DON'T KNOW.

Its a real toss up.

Robin fit the bill best for motive. But the fingerprints in BLOOD were on the gun unless an ESR scientist lied. And it's most suspicious how Bain claims the blackout of memory at the crucial time.

I had a theory at the time - that Robin did it then tried to get David to shoot him. When David fainted instead - maybe after getting a rifle to the head, then Robin shot himself.

Alternately Robin shot the family then forced David to shoot him once he got home, and this is Davids motive for forgetting - or Dad made him promise to say nothing of what occurred, hence the wall of silence.

His taste in jerseys is sus!

[The Pastor]

damn I should of put a don't know option, all my years at AC NEILSON have taught me nothing!

[Deviant Esq]

Have to say "don't know" as well. As written above, if I was on the jury (looks like a real chance at this stage, as I've just received a Jury Summons in the post...), I'd probably have to vote Not Guilty as well, due to the lack of damning evidence against him.

If he's guilty - he's a liar and the Privvy Council has potentially freed a killer.
If he's innocent - he's suffered more than anyone ever should. Not only has he lost 13 of potentially the best years of his life (jailed at 22, now he's 35), but he's lost his whole family and blamed for killing them too. If he is innocent, I'm surprised he didn't just off himself in jail.