Thanks Frits....I only welded my crank at A in your diagram (only a twin cylinder engine), as I had had a crank years ago turn/move (and subsequently go out of true on the output shaft) that I had made out of two TT500 Yamaha cranks for a mates Matchless twin. I use a "Hurth" coupling of my own design which will never rotate, which is basically square holes in the centre two crank webs with a centre mainshaft with corresponding squares each side of the round centre bearing shaft. This is pressed up with only 0.02mm interference but by it's very nature can never rotate (and has never separated/moved). I'm reminded of the old saying "keep it simple stupid

Interesting that I use the original Yamaha TT crankpins (on a 34 mm diameter pin) which even at an interference of the original Yamaha spec at 0.1 mm can still move/slip and is the reason I welded as a precaution more than anything else. So actually IMHO even good design can sometimes (and in the case of a sidecar where the loads are so much more than a solo) come back and bite you in the arse.
As a side note, my "Matchless" replica engine has won the Classic sidecar trophy in NZ 17 times to date and at first attempt in Australia in 2000 took out the Ausy Championship (knocking more than 2 seconds off the classic lap record at Syney's Eastern Creak circuit in the process)....so we'll have no more of this "bad design" BS please from Mr J Quest....sour grapes...not much

Bookmarks