Page 1 of 3 123 LastLast
Results 1 to 15 of 37

Thread: Possibly returning rider - Looking for some thoughts! (robboh)

  1. #1
    Join Date
    17th December 2008 - 13:40
    Bike
    '06 PC37
    Location
    Auckland
    Posts
    88

    Smile Possibly returning rider - Looking for some thoughts! (robboh)

    Hi All,

    Ive lurked here a bit off and on over the years, and finally decided to join

    After a bit of advise / thoughts around options for getting back onto two wheels. This might be a bit of a novel, so bear with me

    Bit of background. Grew up in the Manawatu (perfect bike territory) and rode farm bikes etc from about 12. Got my bike license the day I turned 15. And then stupidly let my learners expire, which meant I had to go through the whole routine again, but including the newly introduced (at the time) skills handling test. Didnt have a cage license until I had to get one for work, at about 21.

    Have always been into 'hyper' 250s, having owned a TZR and a KR1-SP (evil bike - seriously needed a steering damper but I was always too jewish, or too poor, to buy one). Both of which I used to punt around in 250 Proddy at Manfield in the winter series. Was never super quick with the TZR, which was off the pace compared to the RGVs, and only ran the KR1 a couple of times before shifting to AKL.

    Got to run a mate's GP125 at Old Taupo a couple of times too, which was a blast (though I was dog-slow due to not having raced, or even ridden for quite a while at the time)!!

    Shifted up to AKL for work and commuted from Whangaporoa to Albany for a year or so on the KR1. As well as later on when I was carless for a while. The KR1 ended up getting given to a mate in PMR who passed it on to some young guy who raced it again. Was good to hear that. That was about 7 or 8 years ago now. Im mid-30's now.

    About that stage, cages started coming on the scene. Trotting out girls, big dogs, diving, skiing, and all that sort of stuff really necessitates a car. I do a bit of clubsport racing in the car (motokhanas, hillclimbs, dual-sprints at Taupo, that sort of stuff) with an Italian car club (I do like Italian vehicles, they seem to have a bit more soul) as well, which is fun.

    Over the past couple of years, Ive been really starting to get the itch to get another bike, so here I am. Some of the younger guys at work have bikes as well, which doesnt help

    Coupled to all that, the price Im paying for parking in Newmarket is driving me nuts. The price of gas doesnt help, but overall, I dont think commuting a bike is actually much cheaper once you take into account tyres / chains / etc. So Im starting to think a bit more seriously about a bike. The parking building across the road lets us park bikes there for free as long as they arent in the way or taking up cage spots, so that bit is sorted.

    The commute is about 10km each way, so about 100km per week (eg about 5K km per year). From Hillsborough to Newmarket, so its all urban. The back roads I use do have a few steepish hills, and a few fun corners too

    The way I see it, for petrol, cheap running costs, low-cost rego, etc, a scooter would seem to be the go for commuting. But my last experience with scooters is Nifty50's which couldnt pull the skin off a rice pudding. I would worry about not being able to keep up with the traffic, especially on hills. I have a mate in PMR who is a VMoto dealer, and he only has good things to say about the Monza's (he would also tell me if there WERE bad things to say). I reckon a scooter would pay for itself in about 8 months with the savings in parking / petrol.

    A bigger scooter might be an option to solve the power issue, but then dont have cheap rego etc, and still wouldnt be any good for the occasional sunday morning cobweb cleanout, or even possibly the occasional track day. So that leads on to a 'real' bike.

    A 250 would seem a better option than a scooter in terms of power etc for commuting, but since my favourite bike type (250 2T) is basically off the menu these days, I wonder if I think I might find the 250 4T's a bit boring after a few months, especially out of town.

    On the other hand, between the general increase in traffic density, the increased presence of the men-in-blue, IMHO the great overall lowering of general driving skills of motorist in AKL over the past 10 years, and me getting older (and less stupid?) I do find I tend to cruise the cage at just below the ticket threshold (ie 110%). I just dont slow down for corners

    For the 250's, though, the Hyo 250 does look nice, though very heavy! Plus it doesnt seem to have the best of rep's. The Aprilia is just beautiful, but commuting on 250 2T's is a bit of hard work, they arent fun for just laid-back cruising out of town (especially if the road isnt billiard-table smooth), and finally not really that suitable to throw the missus on the back as pillion.

    So that brings me up to the 600's. By the way, Im about 5'6" and ~62 KG, so smaller / lighter bikes are definite must for me, and I think that anything over about a 600 would be just physically too big for me.

    Anyway. Again, the Hyo 650 is cheap, but heavy, not great rep, and not super powerful either. Something like a CBR 600 F4 looks like it would fit the bill for commute and being ok out of town, but they seem to be getting up there in the kays these days and getting a few years old. The current crop of 600s are all hard-out race-reps, and dont really appear to be particularly suitable for regular commuting with very narrow midrange and very hard-arse riding position??

    I do like the look of the Triumph 675 Daytona (quite high seat though?) and Im guessing it would have a little more midrange than the Suzzi / Honda / Yamaha / Kwaka et al??? I reckon the Duke 749 is just beautiful as well, but it would be a bit of a crime to commute one of those, and I suspect would have very high running costs if you were clocking up the kays. Its also getting up in the $$ a bit. I could easily walk out the shop with a new scoot, or a 250, but over that would need some additional saving or talking to the bank manager.

    Reading through the forums over the past few days has shown up a new one I didnt know about, which looks interesting. The Kwaka Ninja 650R. Looks like its got a reasonable riding position for commute / a bit of touring, and a reasonable pillion seat for the occasional missus involvement.

    As a side note, I generally really dont like the look of naked bikes, and have always found that fairings provide far better weather / wind protection, especially out of town.

    So. If you are still with me, does anyone have some pearls of wisdom which might help? Interested in thoughts on the modern 50cc scooters, or 250's v's 600's, or any other left-field suggestions people might have.

    Rob.

  2. #2
    Join Date
    26th November 2008 - 03:48
    Bike
    2023 Husqvarna Svartpilen 401
    Location
    Pokeno, Waikato
    Posts
    634
    Rob, I've been in pretty much the same boat as yourself.
    I actually got a 50cc Honda scooter for commuting. 4 stroke. They're good, but you'll get over it really quickly. It's amazingly cheap to run, doesn't need a WOF, etc, but it can't keep up with the flow of traffic, and so is just not ideal for commuting.
    So if you haven't got your full, you'll be looking to get a 250 in the mean time.
    There are plenty of options, depending on your budget.
    CBR250 is one. New there's the CBR125 or the Ninja250. Or the Honda Hornet 250 is smooth for a second hand 250. If you want to ride prior to getting your full you'll have to get a <250 unless you wait around for these supposed law changes.

    As for 600's and 650's, I've been looking around in the sub-10G price bracket for something that size for when I get my full.
    I've come up with:

    Suzuki: either the GSX650F or the SV650. One's an il4 and the other's a V-twin. I think I prefer the smoothness of an il4, but some would prefer a V.

    Kawasaki: either the Ninja 650R or the ER-6N. Same bike, 1 faired, the other not. I like the exhaust pipe under the engine that exits near the rear wheel.

    The Honda Hornet 600 is a bit out of my price range, unfortunately, but I'd get that if it was a bit cheaper.

    There's also the Suzuki GSR600, which is basically just a detuned, naked GSX-R600, also not a bad looking bike, if you're into the naked look...

    I'm not much fussed on the Hyosungs...

    And anything else is either old or out of my price range.

  3. #3
    Join Date
    23rd August 2008 - 14:37
    Bike
    Speed Triple 1050, '89 Spada
    Location
    Wellington
    Posts
    1,763
    You might prefer faired bikes, but the Triumph Street Triple is not much heavier / bigger than your average 250 - with 108hp (169kg dry). Bars are narrow - good for splitting.

    Dave.
    Quote Originally Posted by FlangMaster
    I had a strange dream myself. You know that game some folk play on the streets where they toss coins at the wall and what not? In my dream they were tossing my semi hardened stool at the wall. I shit you not.

  4. #4
    Join Date
    30th March 2004 - 11:00
    Bike
    2001 RC46
    Location
    Norfshaw
    Posts
    10,455
    Blog Entries
    17
    We've had two replies so far, and yet a GSXR1000RRRRR hasn't been proposed yet?
    Kiwi Biker is slipping....
    ... and that's what I think.

    Or summat.


    Or maybe not...

    Dunno really....


  5. #5
    Join Date
    17th December 2008 - 13:40
    Bike
    '06 PC37
    Location
    Auckland
    Posts
    88
    Thanks for the thoughts so far guys!

    As I said, I am keen on left-field ideas (i.e. those that challenge my somewhat outdated bike preconceptions), so keep 'em coming!

    Sam. The full happened some 18 years ago!
    (Man does time fly!).

    PS. I dont think I would even consider a 50 4T scooter. Small 4T engines are just too gutless.

  6. #6
    Join Date
    30th March 2004 - 11:00
    Bike
    2001 RC46
    Location
    Norfshaw
    Posts
    10,455
    Blog Entries
    17
    Aren't there still some decent 2T scooters on the market? (I'm thinking 125 and above).
    ... and that's what I think.

    Or summat.


    Or maybe not...

    Dunno really....


  7. #7
    Join Date
    9th April 2006 - 14:09
    Bike
    1995 Suzuki Volty (TU250)
    Location
    Auckland
    Posts
    2,120
    Blog Entries
    18
    It seems to me that you have two options (yes, only two!)

    1) Get a single bike that will do both jobs - daily commuting and weekend fun.

    2) Get two different bikes - one for commuting and one for out of town riding.

    I would suggest that you should not, under any circumstances, get a 50cc scooter. They really can't handle Auckland's traffic or the terrain, and if (for example) you wanted to pop over to the North Shore to look at some bike gear in the shops in Barry's Point Road, you just couldn't do it.

    On the other hand my partner (who has been riding for many years and has a sports bike for weekend fun) rides a 180cc scooter for his daily commuting, and it handles motorway traffic brilliantly. Any scooter of 125cc or up would handle your weight easily at motorway speeds.

    If you were to get a decent (but reasonably inexpensive) scooter now, you would have something to ride while you consider your other options. A decent brand will hold its value if you decided to sell it later, or ( ) your wife might decide that she likes it so much she might start commuting on two wheels as well - in which case she can ride it on her learner's licence.

    Good luck with whatever you choose.
    There is no such thing as bad weather; only inappropriate clothing!

  8. #8
    Join Date
    17th December 2008 - 13:40
    Bike
    '06 PC37
    Location
    Auckland
    Posts
    88
    Quote Originally Posted by vifferman View Post
    Aren't there still some decent 2T scooters on the market? (I'm thinking 125 and above).
    My (admittedly somewhat warped) train of thought there is that the price of the bigger scooters, and their ancillary costs like rego (much more expensive compared to the 50cc scooters), mean that there seems to be little point in them.

    The bigger scooters seem like a 'no-mans-land', with additional costs but little additional benefit (other than better power), in that they dont really provide 'weekend' options like going for a hoon, or throwing the missus on the back for a trip to her old mans place Tauranga etc.

    Sure, there are scooters like the Aprillia800 which would do this, but I really dont see the point of those. They wouldnt really provide any major economy benefits (if any) over a 'real' bike in terms of fuel use. And historically I got the most enjoyment from riding out of finding a nice set of smooth, slower-speed twisties, and really getting into some down & dirty scratching.

    My primary driver for thinking about commuting with a bike is to get rid of parking costs, and reduce wear-n-tear on my car (which is getting up in the kays). Fuel doesnt really come into the equation as my commute isnt long enough to see major difference in fuel costs. And Id expect that tyres / other consumables / occasional weekend hooning would actually negate any commuter fuel savings.

    The other minor mental niggle I have is that the bike wont actually get used that much for commuting due to weather and hassle. I could easily see myself deciding each day whether the cage or bike looks like the better option based on the weather. At least the scooter would be a reasonably cheap experiement in those terms.

    In other words, the way I see it, the choice really seems to be that its a 50cc scooter purely for commuting (although, as above, I have concerns around this option so after peoples thoughts and opinions on real-life scooter usage) and getting a real bike.

  9. #9
    Join Date
    26th November 2008 - 03:48
    Bike
    2023 Husqvarna Svartpilen 401
    Location
    Pokeno, Waikato
    Posts
    634
    Quote Originally Posted by robboh View Post
    ...the way I see it, the choice really seems to be that its a 50cc scooter purely for commuting (although, as above, I have concerns around this option so after peoples thoughts and opinions on real-life scooter usage) and getting a real bike.
    Get a real bike. Don't mess about with a scooter. You won't reget it.
    Commute on it when the weather's fine, and go for joy rides in the weekends!
    There are plenty of good, light 600/650cc options.

  10. #10
    Join Date
    9th April 2006 - 14:09
    Bike
    1995 Suzuki Volty (TU250)
    Location
    Auckland
    Posts
    2,120
    Blog Entries
    18
    Quote Originally Posted by samgab View Post
    Get a real bike. Don't mess about with a scooter. You won't reget it.
    Commute on it when the weather's fine, and go for joy rides in the weekends!
    There are plenty of good, light 600/650cc options.
    If you have only one bike, I would agree with this. If you have the luxury of a commuter and a bigger bike for weekends, then I would still suggest looking at a 125 or 150 cc scoot.
    There is no such thing as bad weather; only inappropriate clothing!

  11. #11
    Join Date
    19th April 2008 - 14:26
    Bike
    2013 Victory Hammer 8 Ball
    Location
    Whakaahurangi
    Posts
    640
    welcome aboard robboh

  12. #12
    Join Date
    3rd November 2006 - 20:28
    Bike
    GSXR1000K7,GSXR1100K.
    Location
    auckland
    Posts
    618
    Quote Originally Posted by vifferman View Post
    We've had two replies so far, and yet a GSXR1000RRRRR hasn't been proposed yet?
    Kiwi Biker is slipping....
    It goes without saying!Or what about a DR650?!

  13. #13
    Join Date
    4th October 2008 - 16:35
    Bike
    R1250GS
    Location
    Wellington
    Posts
    10,240
    unless you have got an extremely fuel efficient car even a big bike will use half the petrol....sounds like a 600 650 is what you want...maybe a 500 ....are you looking at new bikes or....?

  14. #14
    Join Date
    17th December 2008 - 13:40
    Bike
    '06 PC37
    Location
    Auckland
    Posts
    88
    Quote Originally Posted by klingon View Post
    If you have only one bike, I would agree with this. If you have the luxury of a commuter and a bigger bike for weekends, then I would still suggest looking at a 125 or 150 cc scoot.
    Thanks for all your thoughts Klingon. Sounds like your thinking is pretty much in line with mine. I either want a single 'proper' bike which is a good allrounder (eg the CBR 600 F4 or similar), or else several more narrowly focused options.

    I hadnt thought of the hand-me-down to the missus option

  15. #15
    Join Date
    17th December 2008 - 13:40
    Bike
    '06 PC37
    Location
    Auckland
    Posts
    88
    Quote Originally Posted by BMWST? View Post
    unless you have got an extremely fuel efficient car even a big bike will use half the petrol....sounds like a 600 650 is what you want...maybe a 500 ....are you looking at new bikes or....?
    For the gas thing. Agreed that even a big bike is going to be cheaper. Especially since its a 2L fiat twin-cam 2L. Im lucky to get 10km/L round town. They are NOT renown for good fuel economy.

    On the other hand, if you are only doing about 400km a month commute, then at current petrol prices, that only equates to say $50 v's $100 a month. Which is pretty much a decent weekend hoon once a month, plus some money aside for tyres / other consumables. For me, Id expect the far bigger saving will be no parking costs, and (hopefully) a more enjoyable trip to work and back.

    Still really pondering at the moment really. If there are good reasons to go brand new, then certainly an option. Just makes it further down the track, and more money spent on parking

    Trouble with brand-new is the depreciation aspect. Though that doesnt seem to be as big a factor with bikes as it is with cars. Or maybe it just looks less due to the lower $$ value involved.

    Im terrible at selling myself up on things, and taking a long time to make a decision (cameras, computers, etc etc) but I usually end up pretty happy with what I end up.

    And yes, a 600-ish does sound like the right direction. I just wonder if the current crop of 600's are just a little too narrow-focus now that Im getting older and lazier. Wringing the neck off a 250 2T is lots of fun when you are 19, but it gets old a bit more quickly these days. Mind you, Im still dead-set against an automatic in the cage, and I still love ripping it up through a set of twisties... so maybe there is still hope for me yet

Thread Information

Users Browsing this Thread

There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •