Which movie?

[jrandom]

But the question is 'which movie'

I wasn't addressing that, I was addressing this:

The rest are just violent movies.

Which is ill-considered; Sin City gets a head-and-shoulders-above-the-rest second placing. Snot 'just a violent movie'.

(re three - I don't agree with one.)

I wait with bated breath in the hope of finding out which.

A small part of me suspects that you're still deciding on that.

[Trumpess]

They are all great movies!
I voted Dusk till Dawn.

Other stan outs include Pulp Fiction and Sin City.
Tarentino is excellent!

[Gubb]

Yeah OK - but I could still argue it's merely a violent comic strip with a 'killer' effects.

Spaaaarta.

Name another Pulp?

It'd odd, but Lock, Stock & Two Smoking Barrels always struck the same chord with me that Pulp Fiction did.

I think it's just the ways that the stories intertwined.

[jrandom]

It'd odd, but Lock, Stock & Two Smoking Barrels always struck the same chord with me that Pulp Fiction did.

S'funny, I was going to say the same thing, but I've never watched Lock Stock sober, so I wasn't sure whether I'd just be talking bollocks.

[Indiana_Jones]

Close between Reservoir dogs and Pulp fiction,

Went with Dogs, not sure way, guess i like seening Chris Penn in fat mode lol

But those are Tarantino's only 2 good films, he's too over rated and believes all the BS written about him really.

-Indy

[jrandom]

... he's too over rated and believes all the BS written about him really.

007XX met him in a bar once and reckons he's a slimeball.

I told her she should've just taken her shoes off.

[Big Dave]

Snot 'just a violent movie'.

(laughing) Compared to pulp fiction it is.

[jrandom]

(laughing) Compared to pulp fiction it is.

A majority of film critics disagree with you.

"It’s violent, it’s sexist, it’s clichéd and it’s trashy. And for once those are all plus-points."

I guess if you gotta ask, you'll never understand...

Edit: You are still trying to decide which of my three remakes you didn't like, aren't you?

[Big Dave]

It'd odd, but Lock, Stock & Two Smoking Barrels always struck the same chord with me that Pulp Fiction did.

I think it's just the ways that the stories intertwined.

Trainspotting i thought the standout in that genre.

[Sully60]

Trainspotting i thought the standout in that genre.

Despite being a very gutted version of the original story.

[jrandom]

Trainspotting i thought the standout in that genre.

'That genre'?

What, movies with lower-class British characters in them?

That's a bit broad to be a 'genre'.

Although, admittedly, this thread was overdue for the use of the word 'genre'. You totally get cool points for being first.

[Big Dave]

Although, admittedly, this thread was overdue for the use of the word 'genre'. You totally get cool points for being first.

If you find anyone with the cred to award them let me know.

[Winston001]

It'd odd, but Lock, Stock & Two Smoking Barrels always struck the same chord with me that Pulp Fiction did.

I think it's just the ways that the stories intertwined.

Completely OT but saw "In Bruges" the other day. It's a worthy successor to Lock Stock and Snatch. Same idiom.

[MTW]

...Tarantino's two strengths are writing and directing pointless conversation so that it sounds witty and profound, and choosing absolutely super music.

I went with Pulp for exactly this reason...YEARS ago my work mates and I would sit outside at lunch break with a tape recording of the dialogue from various parts of this movie and listen to it. Without the picture it's still just as brilliant and just as enjoyable.

[Tank]

Pulp fiction. 100%

Love that movie and watched again just the other day.

I would vote on the poll - but Im still restricted till April'ish (from memory)