Mark Lundy - miscarriage of justice?

**Katman** · 11th July 2013, 23:57

Originally Posted by Winston001

If Christine Lundy expected him home at any moment for an erotic adventure, that is intensely private and not the sort of thing she would be expected to share with others.

I don't buy that at all.

All she would have needed to say was "he'll be home soon - I'll ask him".

There would be no need whatsoever to reveal the purpose of his return.

**scissorhands** · 12th July 2013, 01:58

Dont join a wine club...
too many white collar drunks

**korimako1** · 12th July 2013, 09:08

Originally Posted by Winston001

4. The central issue here is whether the police disclosed the Detective's notes. If not then that is a serious matter albeit perhaps not enough on its own to overturn the conviction.

I dont know whether the detectives notes were disclosed or not but what is a serious matter is that detective Grantham, the officer in charge of the inquiry did some unusual things. And we also now know 12 and a half years later, 5 days before a privy council hearing a document never before released is given to the defence team. this document would have clearly alerted the defence and it was never disclosed by Grantham as required. Why? To secure a conviction, To ensure the defence didnt question the tissue evidence, or did he just have a brain fart and forget.

**Banditbandit** · 12th July 2013, 09:19

Originally Posted by korimako1

I dont know whether the detectives notes were disclosed or not but what is a serious matter is that detective Grantham, the officer in charge of the inquiry did some unusual things. And we also now know 12 and a half years later, 5 days before a privy council hearing a document never before released is given to the defence team. this document would have clearly alerted the defence and it was never disclosed by Grantham as required. Why? To secure a conviction, To ensure the defence didnt question the tissue evidence, or did he just have a brain fart and forget.

Mark !!! Stop using the computers in the training wing and go and clean out your cell!!!

**Katman** · 12th July 2013, 09:43

Originally Posted by Winston001

4. The central issue here is whether the police disclosed the Detective's notes. If not then that is a serious matter albeit perhaps not enough on its own to overturn the conviction.

Well, the article stated that the notebook was undisclosed.

The police should have no trouble disproving that statement if in fact it was offered up to the defense.

**korimako1** · 12th July 2013, 10:34

Originally Posted by Banditbandit

Mark !!! Stop using the computers in the training wing and go and clean out your cell!!!

HaHa wearing your funny pants today are we.

**oldrider** · 12th July 2013, 11:02

Will somebody forward Joe Karam's phone number to Mark Lundy please.

**Drew** · 12th July 2013, 11:04

Originally Posted by oldrider

Will somebody forward Joe Karam's phone number to Mark Lundy please.

Does Lundy need a PR rep too ya reckon?

**oldrider** · 12th July 2013, 13:37

Originally Posted by Drew

Does Lundy need a PR rep too ya reckon?

Joe should be consistent and to do the same for all of those on the same list of dodgy decisions like he thinks Bain got ... he would be really famous then!

**Maha** · 12th July 2013, 15:07

Originally Posted by oldrider

Will somebody forward Joe Karam's phone number to Mark Lundy please.

It's 0800 suckmedry

**Littleman** · 12th July 2013, 19:19

Originally Posted by korimako1

I believe there is a reward out there for anyone who can replicate the drive. the money is safe. it cant be done regardless of drunken boasts. remember it must be done through peak hour traffic, petone and all the way to other side of pnth wait say 10 minutes to do the deed running to and from scene, and then back to petone.
Validate that.

One of the great mysteries is why there isn't some sort of KB/Cannon Ball run equivalent thats run annually on bravado with a conspiratorial mix. Sounds perfect. I would have thought like a red flag to a bull.

**korimako1** · 12th July 2013, 22:01

Originally Posted by Littleman

One of the great mysteries is why there isn't some sort of KB/Cannon Ball run equivalent thats run annually on bravado with a conspiratorial mix. Sounds perfect. I would have thought like a red flag to a bull.

some students wanted to do the lundy 500 but the authorities canned it. just like the courier company, petone to palmerston north and return in under 3 hours. No Efing sense of humour.

**Murray** · 12th July 2013, 22:17

I think the popo cocked up sticking to the time of death. If it had been later in the night or early morning it could have been him.

The witness who saw him was a complete waste of space and the house involved is very, very close to neighbours so early evening murder would have been heard but not at a later time when maybe the victims were asleep??

**Crasherfromwayback** · 12th July 2013, 22:46

Originally Posted by Murray

I think the popo cocked up sticking to the time of death. If it had been later in the night or early morning it could have been him.

The witness who saw him was a complete waste of space and the house involved is very, very close to neighbours so early evening murder would have been heard but not at a later time when maybe the victims were asleep??

That's my guess.