
Originally Posted by
Jerry74
If you actually took the time to read my post it says PERSONALLY!!! MY OPINION... The tyre manufacturers themselves won't recommend mixing tread patterns, even within their own.
of course they dont, it would be like Holden saying put a Ford motor in our car, it'll go better..they want you to remain 'brand loyal' you answer your own reason with the comment below .
It's not because they want you to just buy two of their tyres instead of just one, either (although they do...LOL)
Tyres are designed and built to work as a set. The tread designs themselves compliment one another when dealing with dispersing water and with mechanical grip. The internal constructions of the tyres front and rear are different (due to the geometrical and physical characteristics of a moving motorcycle), yet they also compliment one another.
yes they do, to a point, personal example. I have an FJ1200 in the garage, heavy, old school suspension and has handling 'quirks' that are well documented. many modern tyres are constructed with the modern bike in mind not heavy old dinosaurs like the FJ.. Tyre issues? Rear tyre was a 'semi radial' OEM, when compared to modern day ones.. the sidewall is very pronounced (deep) which allows a fair amount of sidewall flexing and it IS noticeable. Trying Diablo's on the front the weight and elderly styled suspension just ripped it to pieces in less than 6k, and we are not talking hard out riding either.
Best handling from that bike was gained BY mixing brands,,, using the Dunlop series produced for very high loads (Harley specific) on the rear. (Highly rigid carcass which immediately felt more planted on the raod compared to even the dual compound tyres for Wings etc). and a standard diablo or dual compound touring tyre on the front.
Having different tyre brands on the front and rear may have unknown issues (things like handling, wear, etc.). There is no realistic way a tyre manufacturer can test all the possible combinations to make sure they are all safe, so as a blanket method of "CYA" they will just say no...but at the same time it does make sense.
What is far more likely to produce an issue is the profile difference between the fitted tyres, which can also be used to improve a bikes handling characteristics. Again using the FJ example: long low heavy, will run out wide on bends, stands up under braking into bends... so a sportier profile tyre on the front has an advantage, it will allow a 'drop in' effect, which helps to counter the stand up under braking. With the rear profile I found the flatter tyres no issue to handling, in fact the chicken strips were pretty even between both tyres... So there is how mixing tyres can have an advantageous outcome.
It would be best to wait and be able to change both tyres to the same brand if at all possible...the added benefit is that you really get a better idea of how the new tyres truly perform as a set for you if you are switching brands.
Take note of other peoples opinions who have been riding for 20 years and may just know a wee bit too.
Bookmarks