Silly me.
I should never put speed and tolerance in a thread. Too much discussion with bugger all agreement.
It might interest some to hear that 3 years ago I wrote a paper on removing most comp stops, coz nobody stops anyway. I wanted them replaced with Give Ways. That we we could enforce the shit out of the remaining comp stops, the ones that need it, and the rest would be sorted out after the crashes happened. It got as far as the local council, who smiled and that was it.
The rationale behind comp stops is that people occasionally fail to see something before driving out in front of it. If someone stops, that gives them a greater chance to see the thing that is coming.
Now, I know that few will accept that they can fail to see something that is clearly visible, but it happens every day.
Because nobody thinks they are fallible, we fail to understand the stop sign rationale.
Just my few cents on it. Happy to spend hours outlining theory and practice on it, bloody pointless exercise that would be tho. It's not going to change.
True Rastus, not every ComStop needs to be one, but if they are then folk should stop. A lot of accidents in the stretch of road I mentioned, and many close calls.....the other day I saw a truck go left into Shands Rd from Selwyn Rd thru the Stop at maybe 20+k......no way he could have been sure if it was safe or not. Sure enough he missed (couldn't care less about) a black VW driving up Shands at 100k, very close call
The rationale is that it should be a stop control only if certain visibility criteria are met. When they aren't you get people ignoring them. In the end it requires enforcement to get compliance but you still have a BS stop control and you cannot enforce the intersection 24 hours a day. Often put in as a cheap fix after a crash it doesn't really help in the long run, just lessens the impact of the 'true' stop controls.
I'd agree with what you proposed years ago. Give way actually means give way so there really is no need for stop controls anywhere.
Did they all crash?
No stop controls? SMIDSY? Bit of a sweeping statement. But, yeah, nah, yeah. I fail to see the issue with "stop". It's not rocket science, yellow paint is more expensive and I can afford to spend an extra 4 or 5 seconds on my trip to make sure I get home in one piece if it's pointed out to me with signs & said yellow paint that the junction can be dangerous. Enforcement? Let common sense prevail.
Manopausal.
There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)
Bookmarks