
Originally Posted by
Michael Moore
Ken, how does casting/heat treatment/machining time/costs compare to machining the discs from plate, eliminating the hours-long heat treat process? I've watched some videos of modern high-speed CNC mills/CNC lathes with subspindles that zoom through aluminum plate at amazing speed. I realize that there could be issues of "we're already set up to do it this way" but was wondering if you had any idea how things would compare if you were approaching this as a new product with no legacy infrastructure involved?
cheers,
Michael
Michael, it's a good question. One key consideration was the actual material. By using the A390 alloy, the same as we use for our pistons (and in fact the same material used for the alloy bores used by Porsche etc as Will was alluding to) which has very good hard wearing properties, it was a no brainer for us. Yes we could have used our CNC vertical mill to machine out from plates, but the material consideration was key for us at the time. Any commercially rolled/wrought plate, despite maybe having a high Brinell hardness, will and do score and scuff very quickly due to not having any abrasive resistance.
At the time of the design, we did investigate plasma coating of the rubbing faces, some European kart mfgs do have these (really expensive discs done this way, most usually solid), but the coating was near impossible to have done in Oz and expensive. Maybe things have changed.
As to the A390, when used for cylinder bores, the final surface is acid etched to remove the outermost layer of the supporting aluminium to leave the silicone particles exposed to create the very hard wear surface. As this is a fairly complex process, I know/think that Sunnen developed a "honing" process that used a form of felt that was saturated with some abrasive slurry, this abrading the aluminium away leaving the silicone particles proud. This, I think again, was aimed at reconditioners of B&S engines that also use the A390 as a bore material.
Spose I haven't really answered your question if we were to do it again. This being the case, we'd have to reconsider all the factors of today, so who knows. But importantly, it was fun and satisfying to design and make the rotating casting machine and the tooling. I like making stuff. Gotta have something to think about when you wake up at 2.30 am. Sort of no different to you guys doing the Kawasaki 175 barrel (I think it was).
Sorry Husa, but the only day we have ever been in Greymouth ( around 2009 catching the TransAlpine train from ChCh) it was pissing down with rain, so we just went to the pub with a wood fire and didn't even see one palm tree.
"Success is the ability to go from one failure to another with no loss of enthusiasm.”
Bookmarks