First of all, I apologise for the quote festival I am having below. Secondly, I will add right from the beginning (so there is no confusion or doubt) that I work for the importer and original post maker (Eurotred NZ) and therefore any comment's may have a bias.
Mossy, I would agree with you on the above point entirely, on the proviso you are referring to race DOT approved tyres (Pirelli SuperCorsa Pro, Bridgestone R10, Metzeler Racetec, Michelin Power One, Dunlop D211 GP Racer). These are indeed no better (and in many cases, worse) for ROAD use. They are designed for racing, and nothing but - cold use, wet grip and longevity have no place in the designs of these tyres, and they are not designed to provide grip below about 70deg. HOWEVER - a sports tyre (Bridgestone S20 (as being given away in this thread) Michelin Pilot Power 2CT, Continental Sport Attack, Dunlop Qualifier etc) are designed for road use, and in that have a lower temp window (say, 20-100deg) for use, they are designed including elements like Silica (for wet weather and cold condition riding) and then with Bridgestone elements like RC-polymer to control the temprature effects of Silica. These tyres are designed for Sport's bikes in road use. This means profiles that are made to suit bikes like that.
Jrandom, agreed - as above, a DOT race tyre is not really appropriate for the road, and SuperCorsa's fall under that. a Sports tyre however, is road appropriate.
Yes, S20 is a development of BT016-PRO - a sport's road tyre. R10 is Bridgestone's DOT race tyre for 600 Supersport racing/F2.
S20's could be for you then - in this particular market segment the Bridgestone's are renoun for their wet performance, and S20 is aiming to improve on that.
Hitcher, I have to disagree with you here.
The first part of your post refering to OEM tyres is accurate. OEM tyres are usually, to put it bluntly, shit. This applies to all OEM tyres, not just Bridgestone, but Dunlop, Michelin, etc. There are many reasons for this which I won't go into her but the main one is cost to the manufacturers. My point is that a BT021 or BT023 OEM tyre (on a new bike) is not the same tyre or quality you will buy through a shop - the constuction and compound is different and almost always better.
The Rosso's are a step further away towards race use than S20 Hitcher, they are similar to Bridgestone BT003-RS, or Michelin Power Pure - these are designed with trackdays and fast, dry road riding in mind.
I disagree with the second paragraph in that a sport's tyre for road use (as mentioned near the start of my reply) is a different animal to a race tyre that is road legal.
Correct - these are examples of sport's road tyres, that do as designed what most race tyres cannot. Because of this they are often a better road choice for Sport's Bikes than Full Sports touring tyres (Bridgestone BT023, Conti Road Attack, Michelin Pilot Road 3).
Hope I haven't bored any of you to tears...
Jay Lawrence #37
To clarify on my essay above, tyre catogories seem to be the main issue here. Below are the catagories as I see them;
Sport-Touring
These tyres are designed for potentially heavier bikes (FJR1300, Bandit's etc). They are made for lower temprature applications (0deg to 80deg - ish). They include elements in the construction of the tyre to suit wet and cold weather riding (Silica). The profile is probably flatter than a sportier tyre and give very neutral feedback to the rider (they don't tip in rapidly, you will have to work a bit more to lean them).
Common tyre's in NZ in this catagory are; (I have only listed current model tyres to save confusion, and there are certainly models I have missed)
Bridgestone BT023
Michelin Pilot Road 3
Pirelli Angel ST
Metzeler Z8
Continental Road Attack 2
Sport's/Hypersports
These tyres are designed for sports bikes (600's and 1000's, and similar) that are used on the road. They would also be appropriate for bike's like Hayabusa/Blackbird, or naked or touring bikes that are ridden a little harder. They will usually have elements like Silica to give them better wet performance, in the case of some brands (Bridgestone being the one I am familiar with) have other additional elements like RC-polymer, which stops the Silica bleeding out of the tyre at higher temprature. This gives them a wider useful temprature corridor (say, 15deg-100deg - ish). They will likely have a slightly more agressive profile that makes the bike turn in quicker than a sport-touring tyre. They are still designed to be very competent in the wet and cold, and should give reasonable milage.
Common tyre's in NZ in this category are; (I have only listed current model tyres to save confusion, and there are certainly models I have missed)
Bridgestone BT016-PRO and S20, as featured in this thread
Continental Sport Attack
Michelin Pilot Power 2CT
Dunlop Qualifier (I think)
Pirelli Diablo Rosso II
Trackday - also think fast road use
These tyre's are made for very fast road use, and trackdays. There profiles probably mimic the full DOT race tyres, but the compounding is made so they don't require a warmer to get to the correct opperating tempratures. The temp corridors for these are likely 50deg-120deg. Because of this they won't be very friendly in the wet (no Silica) and they won't last as long (softer compuond, not as hard wearing).
Common tyre's in NZ in this category are; (I have only listed current model tyres to save confusion, and there are certainly models I have missed)
Bridgestone BT003-RS
Metzeler Racetec K3 compound
Michelin Pilot Pure
Continental Race attack Street
Pirelli Diablo Rosso Corsa
DOT race tyre
These are all about the laptime. Road legal but only because the class of racing specifies they must be. They are designed for warmers, and won't get warm enough without them. (temp corridor 80deg plus) They are not designed for wet grip, or milage. The profiles are ultra-agressive for racing, a potentially bad mix when the tyres are run without warmers, the feedback will be minimal.
Common tyre's in NZ in this category are; (I have only listed current model tyres to save confusion, and there are certainly models I have missed)
Bridgestone R10
Continental Race Attack
Michelin Power One
Metzeler Racetec
Pirelli Supercorsa Pro
Dunlop D211 GP racer (I think)
The tyre's Eurotred (NZ) are giving away to two guys to test are S20. They are designed for road use, up to and including the odd trackday, also for wet road use. For real world use on most sports bikes, they should be the best tyre avalible - this is what Eurotred (NZ) is trying to find out with this promotion!
Cheers Guys - pardon my spelling, I can't use a spell check on this PC![]()
Jay Lawrence #37
Jay for P.M
Well, that clears that up then!
"Sorry Officer, umm.... my yellow power band got stuck wide open"
I'm guessing that some new rubber for my old (1980) Moto Guzzi is out of the question then? You know - narrow 18" wheels?
Tough call. I'm really struggling with your revelation that OEM tyres are different to the same models bought through a shop.
This is an arrangement that seems detrimental to the reputations of both the manufacturers of the tyres and the motorcycles to which those tyres are fitted. It's a revelation that also presumes that there would be some labelling distinction, so that manufacturers could distinguish between tyres in the event of a warranty claim being made. But perhaps they choose to swallow any and all losses on the basis that having been disenchanted by a suboptimal experience with OEM tyres, a rider will replace with the same model tyre when the OEMs wear out. It's also an arrangement, if indeed it is true, that paints a particularly bad picture of a tyre manufacturer's desire to make a sale at any cost.
In my case Mr Kawasaki, Mr Honda, Mr Yamaha and Mr Suzuki's decision to fit their steeds with OEM Bridgestones has resulted in a statistically repeatable trend of associating Mr Bridgestone's "sports touring" tyres with shit handling. That is why, like some professional tyre reviewers, I now subscribe to a view that the best fate for 020s, 021s and probably 023s, is to push them into a big pile and set them alight.
Thanks to your revelation I now know that I should get documentary evidence from Mr Bridgestone, on the unlikely event that I am ever tempted to try a set of his tyres, that the tyres I am about to buy are of a superior standard to those that may be fitted as OEMs.
"Standing on your mother's corpse you told me that you'd wait forever." [Bryan Adams: Summer of 69]
Hitcher.... surely you jest?
The OEM BT 016 tyres ARE labelled differently.
On the 08-10 sem fiddy, for instance, the OEM rear BT016 was only two compound, not three as in the over-the-counter ones.
OEM tyres are often made lighter, or to a manufacturer spec.
Anyway... I digress... I WILL be trying the new ones.
There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)
Bookmarks